Skip to main content

February 9 The End Does Not Justify the Means

Do not despise a thief if he steals to satisfy his hunger when he is starving. Yet if he is caught, he must pay sevenfold, though it cost him all the wealth of his house. ~Proverbs 6:30-31

This is what the Lord almighty says: “Administer true justice; show mercy and compassion to one another. Do not oppress the widow or the fatherless, the alien or the poor. In your hearts, do not think evil of each other.” ~Zechariah 7:9-10

Question: What do you think the Lord thinks of the fact that we live in a land of abundance yet are surrounded by so much physical need? Did He provide abundance so that some can become well off or so that none would have need?

In his novel “Les Misérables” Victor Hugo depicts the verses from Proverbs for today. A poor man steals a loaf of bread, is caught and in the process of his paying seven-fold, he becomes what he was not before, a true criminal. It is only through the offer of grace by a priest that the man recognizes the choice he has to continue the life in which he had been trained to see himself or be renewed and transformed into a new creation. Of course, the point of this novel is to demonstrate how cruel man can be when those in power are governed too heavily by rules without compassion. It was written in a day in which these types of circumstances were actually experienced and thus believable.

That’s not our story today. With the abundance of food and pantries and a much more lenient justice system, we may find this story implausible. For Solomon to make this a Proverb, however, makes one wonder if this type of injustice was known in his day. And, if God made sure that out of Solomon’s more than 3,000 proverbs, this one made it into the final cut of scripture, He must know that there is something for us to still be able to learn to add to wisdom today.

First of all, let’s consider the context. Is this proverb really about a loaf of bread? If so, why would it be in the middle of a teaching about the woes of adultery? I don’t know about your Bible, but in my NIV Bible, the heading before Proverbs 6:20 says: “Warning against Adultery.” So, why, in the middle of a discourse on adultery is Solomon, all of a sudden talking about bread?  If you read the actual text from Proverbs 6:20-35, you will notice that in verse 26, Solomon warns his listeners : “The prostitute reduces you to a loaf of bread, and the adulteress preys upon your life.”

We could be tempted to take these verses 6:30-31, out of context and rail against the injustice of the powerful to overly punish a poor man for stealing a loaf of bread such as Victor Hugo did. Consider, a whole novel was written on these two verses and it was an acceptable subject. However, I believe that what Solomon is angling for here is another way of talking about the danger of small steps, whether it has to do with the temptation of food, or an inappropriate relationship. You may get away with either one, but if you are caught, you will receive punishment because that is justice. The end does not justify the means.

By the way, just so you know, while we may think that the punishment of paying seven times for a loaf of bread may be overblown, God Himself directs Moses in Exodus 22:3:B, “A thief must certainly make restitution, but if he has nothing, he must be sold to pay for his theft.” Solomon wasn’t coming up with this on his own, he was re-enforcing what God Himself had already said when He laid down His law at the exodus.

In our western thinking, this all sounds harsh. We are so used to giving a pass, it’s only a loaf of bread after all. It’s only a cup of coffee with a co-worker. It’s only a little white lie. It’s only, it’s only, it’s only…isn’t that what grace is all about?

No!! A very high price was paid to show grace, for the stolen loaves of bread to the lives that are stolen every day through other forms of sin that are more obvious. There is no pass, there is a price which was paid at the cross. That loaf of bread, that stolen opportunity wasn’t cheap, just because you didn’t pay it fully doesn’t mean it was written off like a tax benefit.  Being holy is costly. Little foxes are deadly.

When Solomon uses the loaf of bread to talk about sin and its consequences, it is parallel to Nathan’s story about the Lamb when he confronted David with his sin in 2 Samuel 12. By the way, that was another incident involving adultery. It is another attempt to cause us to think about the consequences of our actions beyond the immediate gratification that we experience in the moment. It’s again calling the listener to use obedience to God’s Word, wisdom and prudence to choose the path of light before starting down the wrong road.

The challenge for us today is, how to teach the same to our listeners. We should all be a Solomon to someone. How do we help our listeners do the same? What word picture can we paint that will help our listeners consider the consequences of their actions beyond the moment? We’d better find an answer if we want to guide them away from the wrong path.

Prayer: Oh Lord, when we have a chance to be a positive influence, and to share your wisdom, please give us good words that relate to the people we get to talk to. In Jesus’ name, amen.

Song: “I Cherish the Treasure of You” Steve Green

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

211. The Sons of Thunder's Request

Matthew 20:20-28 , Mark 10:35-45 , Key verse: "Whoever wants to become great among you must be your servant, and whoever wants to be first must be slave of all." Mark 10:43B-44 In our readings for yesterday, in which Jesus outlined what was about to happen to Him, for His disciples, the passage in Luke ends: "The disciples did not understand any of this. It's meaning was hidden from them, and they did not know what He was talking about." ( Luke 18:34 ) Now, we see just how truly clueless they were. Jesus had laid out a plan before them of pain and suffering and death and now James and John are focused on a promotion. The disconnect is so obvious. It's really not important to know whether James and john came up with this request on their own or if their mother put them up to it. The request was made and James and John thought that they could handle the responsibility that would come with it. What is that saying, "Fools rush in where angels fe...

204. Come Like a Child

Psalm 127 , Matthew 19:13-15 , Luke 18:15-17 , Mark 10:13-16 Key Verse: Jesus said, "Let the little children come to me, and do not hinder them, for the kingdom of heaven belongs to such as these." Matthew 19:14 The attitude of the disciples isn't much different than the attitude of many people, even Christians, today. Instead of seeing children as a blessing from the Lord, too many regard them as a burden to bear that gets in the way of our own selfish happiness. Family size is determined by what we think we can afford rather than openness to God's blessing, trusting God to provide. Satan hates children. Children represent innocence. The sooner he can corrupt and or damage a child, the happier he is. This is why Jesus warned in Matthew 18:6: "If anyone causes one of these little ones who believe in Me to sin, it would be better for him to have a large millstone hung around his neck and to be drown in the depths of the sea." To corrupt or damage ...

174. Pleading for the Fig Tree

Proverbs 27:18 , Luke 13:6-9 Key Verse: He who tends a fig tree will eat its fruit, and he who looks after his master will be honored. Proverbs 27:18 We have here three main characters: a master, who acquired the tree in hopes of eventually enjoying its fruit, a servant, who looks to the tree to reflect his care and attention, and lastly, the tree itself. The master has the right to expect his investment to pay off. The servant, who has obviously put much effort into the tree, would also like to see fruit. The servant's interest is not only to show his own talent in gardening, but because he wants to please his master. Both the servant and the master are dependent upon the tree to do what it was designed to do. Their little parable is an interesting way for Jesus to finish off His exhortation to, "repent or perish."  God is the Master. He had a purpose for you before you were even born. ( Jeremiah 1:5 & Psalm 139:16 ) He planted you on this earth to ful...